Two Monuments, One Long-Standing Ban
For as long as they have been units of the National Park System, Castle Mountains National Monument in California and the original core of Craters of the Moon National Monument in Idaho have been closed to hunting. This month the National Park Service moved to change that. A proposed rule published in the Federal Register on November 16, 2026 would write hunting into the regulations for both places, with a short list of safety and resource limits attached.
The proposal is a formal rulemaking, not a done deal. It is a proposed rule, it carries the regulation identifier RIN 1024-AF13, and it appears in the Federal Register as document 2026-23228. Nothing changes on the ground until the agency reviews public comments, issues a final rule and publishes it. For hunters who have eyed the lava fields of southern Idaho or the Joshua tree country along the Nevada line, though, it is the clearest sign yet that the doors could open.
What the Park Service Is Proposing
The rule would add new special regulations to Part 7 of Title 36 of the Code of Federal Regulations. Castle Mountains would get a new section 7.98, and the original Craters of the Moon monument would get section 7.101. Both would begin the same way: hunting is allowed, notwithstanding other NPS rules, and it must follow federal law and the laws of the state.
In practical terms, California and Idaho wildlife agencies would keep their familiar role. Seasons, tags and bag limits would continue to come from the states. The Park Service says it does not anticipate changes to state seasons or tag quotas for specific species as a result of the rule. A hunter would still need the right license and the right tag, and the species would still need an open season.
Two guardrails apply in both monuments. First, species protected under the Endangered Species Act cannot be hunted, even if state law would otherwise allow it. Second, each superintendent would be able to set closures, restrictions and conditions that are the minimum necessary to prevent a significant impact to public safety, to the historic and scientific features the monument was created to protect, or to threatened and endangered species. Except in emergencies, superintendents would have to consult the relevant state agency first and tell the public through the usual channels, including the superintendent's compendium.
Interior Secretary Doug Burgum framed the plan in terms of heritage. "Hunting is part of America's heritage, and hunters are some of our country's greatest conservationists," he said. "President Trump has made clear that our hunting heritage deserves to be protected and promoted—because conservation and access go hand in hand. This proposal builds on the President's commitment by expanding hunting opportunities while respecting state wildlife management authority and safeguarding the natural resources we all treasure."
Castle Mountains: Desert Water and a Working Mine
A young monument on the Nevada line
President Obama created Castle Mountains National Monument on February 16, 2016, under the Antiquities Act, through Proclamation 9394. It covers 20,920 acres in the eastern Mojave Desert in northeastern San Bernardino County, California, tucked against the Nevada state line. The monument is bordered on three sides by Mojave National Preserve, which the Park Service also manages, and it serves as a habitat link between the New York Mountains to the northwest and the Piute Mountains to the southeast.
The Park Service describes some of the finest Joshua tree forest in the Mojave, with pinyon pine and juniper at higher elevations and a native desert grassland that is a hotspot of plant diversity. A herd of desert bighorn sheep lives on the steep slopes. The agency also lists the Townsend's big-eared bat, California leaf-nosed bat, Swainson's hawk, golden eagle, desert tortoise, Bendire's thrasher and gray vireo among the wildlife species of special concern, alongside prehistoric rock art and archaeological sites.
The two proposed limits
The rule written with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife adds two specific restrictions. Hunting would be off limits within 200 yards of any wildlife watering place, a term the rule defines in line with California law to include waterholes, springs, seeps and man-made devices such as guzzlers, horizontal wells and small impoundments under an acre. The agency's reasoning is simple desert arithmetic: water is scarce, bighorn, mule deer and desert tortoises depend on a handful of sources, and a person sitting near one can keep animals from drinking. The rule text also calls ambushing thirsty animals at a water source unsporting, a point that will resonate with hunters who prize fair chase.
The second limit is a one-mile no-hunting buffer around the Castle Mountain Mine. The mine operates inside the monument boundary on land administered by the Bureau of Land Management under a BLM plan of operations, and the buffer is meant to protect its workers. Neither restriction would stop someone from retrieving a lawfully taken animal from inside a restricted zone, as long as the animal was not hunted there.
The Park Service notes that hunting is already authorized on more than one million acres of NPS-administered land around Castle Mountains, which gives context to the size of this addition.
Craters of the Moon: Lava, Sagebrush and Short-Range Weapons
From 54,000 acres to 753,000 and back to a question of boundaries
Craters of the Moon has a more tangled administrative history. President Coolidge proclaimed it a national monument on May 2, 1924 to protect what his proclamation called a weird and scenic landscape peculiar to itself. For decades it covered roughly 54,000 acres. In November 2000, President Clinton's Proclamation 7373 expanded it to about 753,000 acres to protect the 65-mile Great Rift volcanic zone, and split management between the Park Service and the BLM. In 2002, Congress designated the NPS-administered portion of the expansion as a national preserve.
That split is why the rule applies only to what it calls the original monument. Hunting is already permitted in Craters of the Moon National Preserve and on the BLM-administered portions of the monument. The new rule would extend it into the pre-2000 core, where it has never been allowed.
Limits worked out with Idaho Fish and Game
Developed in coordination with the Idaho Department of Fish and Game, the Idaho provisions are tougher than California's. Hunters in the original monument would be restricted to short-range weapons as Idaho law defines them. That list covers shotguns firing slugs or double-aught or larger buckshot, muzzleloaders of at least .45 caliber for deer, pronghorn, mountain lion or gray wolf and at least .50 caliber for elk, moose, bighorn sheep, mountain goat or black bear, bows with a peak draw weight of at least 40 pounds, crossbows of at least 150 pounds, straight-wall centerfire handguns, and certain pre-charged pneumatic airguns. Modern centerfire rifles are out.
The explanation is geography. The open lava terrain offers few natural backstops, and rifle bullets can travel well beyond a hunter's target. The agency says tying the definition to state law should also make it easier to communicate to hunters.
The second restriction closes the NPS-administered area north and northwest of Highway 20/93. That strip, roughly 5,000 acres, is currently limited to administrative use. It holds the Yurt Campground and Administrative Campground, the park's entire potable water system and wellheads, electrical infrastructure, a solar array, a pumphouse, a chlorinator building, sensitive archaeological sites and a historic trail listed on the National Register. The Park Service says that acreage is less than 10 percent of what would otherwise open to hunting, so the closure would be a modest trim on the overall opportunity.
The Legal Basis
An executive order sets the clock
The immediate driver is Executive Order 14429, "Reinvigorating America's Hunting Heritage," signed September 17, 2026. Section 2(a) directs the Secretary of the Interior to allow hunting of species not covered by the Endangered Species Act within Castle Mountains and the original Craters of the Moon monument within 90 days. The order states that appropriately managed hunting would not put the monuments' historic and scientific objects at risk. Counting from the signing date, the 90 days run out in mid-December 2026.
Why a rule is needed at all
The existing barrier is a regulation, not a statute. Under 36 CFR 2.2, hunting is prohibited in units of the National Park System unless federal law specifically mandates or authorizes it, and the proposed rule notes that no such law exists for Castle Mountains or the original Craters of the Moon. Part 7 exists for exactly this kind of case: special regulations for individual park areas that can relax, tighten or modify the general rules in Parts 1 through 5.
The Park Service also leans on parallel authority from Congress for neighboring land. The statute governing Mojave National Preserve and the law that created Craters of the Moon National Preserve both let the agency, after consulting the state, designate areas and periods where no hunting is allowed for reasons such as public safety and resource protection. The proposal gives monument superintendents similar discretion.
The monuments themselves were created under the Antiquities Act, codified at 54 U.S.C. 320301. The proclamations protect specific objects of historic and scientific interest, and the agency argues its mitigations are designed so that hunting does not jeopardize them.
Environmental review
The Park Service does not expect to prepare a detailed environmental impact statement. It anticipates the rule will be covered by a categorical exclusion under the National Environmental Policy Act, unless extraordinary circumstances apply. It says it will document the exclusion if it is used. The agency also calls the rule significant under Executive Order 12866 but expects minor economic effects, and it treats the action as a deregulatory measure under Executive Order 14192.
Comment Period: Short and Closing Soon
This is the part of the proposal readers can act on. Comments are open now and must be received by 11:59 p.m. Eastern on December 16, 2026. That is a 30-day window, half the 60 days Interior policy normally calls for. The Park Service explains that the 90-day deadline in the executive order is a special case: a 60-day comment period would leave only 15 days for internal review, comment analysis and publication of a final rule.
Comments can be filed through the Federal Register website or regulations.gov by searching for RIN 1024-AF13, or by mail to the National Park Service Division of Regulations, 7206 National Seashore Lane, Berlin, MD 21811. The agency says it will not accept comments by email or fax, and submissions must include "National Park Service" or "NPS" along with the RIN. Comments may be posted publicly with any personal information included.
Tribal consultation is also under way. Craters of the Moon staff have shared the executive order with the Shoshone-Bannock Tribes of Fort Hall and the Shoshone-Paiute Tribes of the Duck Valley Reservation. The superintendent has met with a Shoshone-Bannock representative about concerns tied to the Fort Bridger Treaty of 1868, and the Northwestern Band of the Shoshone Nation is also a consulting tribe. Castle Mountains staff plan to meet with the Fort Mojave and Chemehuevi tribes.
What It Means for Hunters
If finalized as written, the rule would add two new places to hunt, but not a free-for-all. Idaho hunters would have to leave the rifle at home in the original monument and plan around the closed northern strip. California hunters in the Castle Mountains would have to map every spring, seep and guzzler and stay 200 yards back. In both places state tags and seasons still govern, so no one should plan a trip on the strength of a proposal.
The Park Service itself expects the effect on total hunting days to be small, noting that the monuments make up a modest share of the land already open nearby. What the new ground might add, it says, is variety in where a hunter can go. It also acknowledges some non-hunting visitors could be bothered by noise, though it expects those costs to be minimal.
Jessica Bowron, who is exercising the delegated authority of the Director of the National Park Service, said, "These proposed regulations reflect our commitment to expanding access while still protecting the resources these monuments were established to preserve." She added that the agency worked with California and Idaho "to craft a rule that respects their role in managing wildlife and gives our superintendents the tools they need to protect visitors, employees and sensitive resources."
The rule also lands inside a larger push. Earlier this year Interior and the Park Service announced a separate effort to remove localized hunting closures and restrictions at park units where hunting is already authorized by Congress, and a separate Alaska preserve rulemaking drew its own fight. Conservation groups have already pushed back on parts of that broader agenda, and the monument proposal could draw comments from both sides: hunters who want access and preservation advocates who worry about wildlife and quiet in places set aside for their scientific and scenic value. Anyone who cares can weigh in before December 16, and the final rule, expected to follow quickly given the executive order's timeline, will show how much of the comment record changes the text.

Comments
Comments are moderated. Please keep it civil — see our community guidelines.
No comments yet — be the first.