For more than six decades, Bill Jakob has chased striped bass in the surf off Montauk, the far eastern point of Long Island where the Atlantic piles up against the rocks. He remembers nights when he would fish until dawn and walk off the beach with eight or nine stripers, some of them pushing 40 pounds. Any surfcaster today would call that a career night. Back then it happened often enough that it felt like it would last forever.
It didn't. After years of hard fishing pressure, the big runs dried up. Jakob, now president of the Montauk Surfcasters Association, is honest about how it happened.
“I’m part of the problem, back in the years. I ran party boats, we slayed fish with reckless abandon,” he told The Associated Press.
That kind of confession is becoming common on the docks and beaches of the Northeast. As reported by AP journalists Patrick Whittle and Robert F. Bukaty, a growing number of anglers, guides and scientists now say the fish many of them built their lives around is in real trouble.
Eight Straight Bad Years in the Chesapeake
The number that worries scientists most comes from the Chesapeake Bay. Regulators said last week that striped bass have now gone eight years in a row with poor reproduction in the bay, which is the most important nursery the species has. Along much of the Atlantic coast, the population has declined.
Anglers have been noticing it for a while. Fewer stripers show up where they used to, and young fish are getting harder to find. Researchers who study the species say those worries are justified, and that overfishing is only one cause.
The list of other suspects is long. Many scientists point first to years of warming water. Low river flows, drought and pollution are on the list too, along with possibly more predation from seals and sharks. Taken together, these pressures have experts and fishermen asking a hard question: would tighter fishing limits even be enough to bring the fish back?
How a Striper Gets Its Start
Striped bass hatch in fresh or brackish water and spend their early years in the estuaries where rivers meet the sea. Whether a new generation survives depends heavily on the weather. Stripers do best after cool, wet springs.
Scientists recognize four major spawning stocks on the Atlantic coast, but one matters far more than the others. Up to 90% of stripers spawn and grow up in the Chesapeake Bay. According to Toni Kerns, fisheries policy director with the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission, the interstate body that regulates striped bass, the fish suffer and populations can drop when freshwater flows run too low, as they do in droughts, or when spring and summer temperatures run too high.
Chris Batsavage, who chairs the commission’s striped bass management board, said conditions have been poor in recent years and that fewer fish have entered the population going back to 2019.
“Low precipitation and waters that warm quickly result in weak year classes,” Batsavage said. “It seems like it’s environmentally driven.”
For anglers, that explanation cuts two ways. On one hand, it suggests the decline isn't only the fault of the people holding rods. On the other, rule changes alone can't fix a problem caused by the weather. Regulators can shorten a season or narrow a slot limit. They can't make the spring wetter or the bay cooler.
Overfished, but Not Being Overfished
The commission’s official assessment uses a distinction that confuses many people outside fisheries science. It considers the striped bass stock overfished, meaning the population is below where it should be. At the same time, it says overfishing is not happening right now, meaning current fishing levels aren't the main thing pushing the stock lower.
Stripers are caught by both commercial and recreational fishermen, but the recreational fishery is far larger. Most fish caught recreationally are released alive. Still, not every released fish survives. Regulators have traditionally assumed that 9% of released stripers die afterward. Newer data suggests the real figure could be under 5%. That difference matters a great deal when managers calculate how many fish anglers are actually killing.
Keeper rules generally limit harvest to fish in a range of about 28 to 31 inches, and the rules vary by state and location. Striped bass are popular with catch-and-release anglers, and today it is more common to catch bigger bass, many well over 31 inches. That sounds like good news, but it isn't. Those large fish are what remains of earlier, stronger year classes, and few young fish are coming up behind them.
An $8 Billion Fish
Striped bass are more than a weekend hobby. According to people in the industry, the guides, boat trips, gear, bait and hotel rooms that depend on stripers add up to roughly $8 billion in economic impact and as many as 100,000 jobs in the U.S. alone. Up and down the coast, businesses rely on the fish showing up every season.
There is an ecological cost too. Stripers are higher-level predators that help keep populations of smaller fish in check. Losing them would ripple through the coastal food web, and economically it would threaten that $8 billion industry and the tens of thousands of jobs connected to it.
Patrick Paquette, government affairs coordinator for the Massachusetts Striped Bass Association and a member of an interstate advisory panel on the regulations, doesn't soften his outlook.
“Striped bass as we know it is going to collapse,” Paquette said.
“Sometime around 2029, 2030 it’s going to go off a cliff,” he said, “and it’s going to be ugly.”
“When You Go There in Perfect Conditions, You Catch Nothing”
Few people know the Long Island striper scene better than John Skinner. He has fished those waters for more than 50 years, has written a book about striped bass fishing, and runs a YouTube channel on the subject with more than 100,000 followers. He says spots that were once reliable have gone completely dead.
“I’m not saying the fishing is bad. I’m saying when you go there in perfect conditions, you catch nothing,” Skinner said. “Absolutely nothing.”
Anglers across the Northeast told the same story this summer and fall. The big schools that used to be plentiful are gone. The fish that remain are clearly older, which suggests years of failed reproduction are starting to show up in the catch. Smaller schools, mostly big fish, and very few young fish behind them is what a population living on old year classes looks like.
Fishermen don't agree on what is to blame. Some think years of heavy harvest are now showing up as a smaller population. Others blame sharks, whose comeback after years of conservation efforts has added competition for the fish. Many accept that warming is part of the picture but don't think it explains everything.
Fights Over the Rulebook
The debate over what to do has already become heated. In June 2025, Gentleman’s Pursuits reported that the Delmarva Fisheries Association and 14 other fishing groups had filed a federal lawsuit against the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission over its striped bass rules. That fight showed how closely fishing communities and businesses watch every change to the regulations.
Now some anglers are calling for tighter rules instead of looser ones. Some fishermen said stricter regulations, or even a moratorium on fishing, may be the only way to keep the population from falling to a dangerously low level. The question is whether those measures would be enough when so much of the decline seems tied to river flows and water temperatures that no fisheries board controls.
The Lesson From the Last Crash
Older anglers have seen this before. Striped bass populations crashed in the 1980s, and strict limits were part of what brought them back in one of the great conservation recoveries in American sport fishing. Many of today's veteran anglers fished through the boom that followed, and they are now watching it fade. The difference this time, scientists suggest, is that the environment itself may be working against a recovery.
Planning Around a Smaller Future
For the man who keeps a surf rod by the door and plans his fall around the migration, the news is hard to hear. Paquette, a longtime angler himself, said that without drastic action he fears the end of striped bass fishing. His advice to people counting on stripers in retirement is blunt.
“If you’re a guy who thought he was going to retire and striped bass fish, and you’re planning on retiring soon, get a different plan,” Paquette said.
Anglers can still do a few things now: handle released fish carefully and quickly, and pay attention to the commission’s public comment periods when new rules are proposed. None of that will make the Chesapeake rain in spring. But in a fishery where most of the catch goes back in the water, every fish that survives counts.
Jakob, who by his own account once ran party boats that “slayed fish with reckless abandon,” has seen both ends of the striper story. Whether the next generation of surfcasters at Montauk gets anything like the nights he remembers may be decided over the next few years.
