The 5 Best Fish to Catch This Fall

The 5 Best Fish to Catch This Fall

<

As the leaves turn and temperatures begin to drop, something shifts in the water — fish that spent the summer in deeper, cooler zones start moving aggressively, feeding heavily to prepare for winter. Fall is widely regarded by serious anglers as the most productive season of the year, offering a rare window where trophy-sized fish are actively chasing bait in accessible waters. The cooling water temperatures trigger feeding frenzies that can make even a modest outing feel exceptional, provided you know which species to target and where to find them. Understanding seasonal fish behavior, the right tackle to match it, and how water temperature affects feeding patterns are the fundamentals that separate a frustrating day on the water from one you'll talk about for years.

Brown Trout: The Fall Spawner Worth Chasing

Brown trout are one of the premier targets of autumn because they are fall spawners, typically triggered into movement when water temperatures drop into the mid-40s. In most regions, peak spawning activity runs through October and November, which causes big fish to move from their deep summer lies into shallower gravel runs and tributary streams — places you'd never expect to find them earlier in the year. The best fishing happens when browns are staging in the days before the spawn, feeding aggressively to build energy reserves. Rather than targeting fish actively on redds, focus on pools, current seams, and eddies above and below spawning areas, where pre- and post-spawn fish will crush large streamers, minnow baits, and crawfish-imitating crankbaits. Always check local regulations, as many rivers enforce catch-and-release rules or seasonal closures during the spawn to protect the fishery.

Walleye: Fall's Most Underrated Trophy Bite

Walleye earn their reputation as a fall standout because every calorie counts for them heading into winter — the fish that were finicky and tight-lipped all summer become voracious predators from mid-September through mid-November. As water temperatures cool, baitfish school up near rocky shorelines and current breaks, and walleye lock in right behind them, making them far easier to locate than at any other time of year. Target areas along the first drop-off in shallow, weedy lakes, or look for them stacking on rock piles, river mouths, and deep humps in larger bodies of water like Lake Erie or Minnesota's Leech Lake. A classic jig-and-minnow combo worked slowly along structure remains one of the deadliest presentations, though trolling larger shad-bodied crankbaits works well on open-water fish in early fall. With hunting season pulling many anglers off the water, you'll often have some of the best walleye bites of the year almost entirely to yourself.

Striped Bass: Ride the Fall Migration

When fall rolls around on the Atlantic coast, striped bass begin their annual southbound journey, following massive schools of baitfish migrating to warmer waters for the winter. This makes autumn prime time for chasing stripers, as they're running and feeding in huge numbers along predictable coastal corridors. The fish hug the shoreline tightly, meaning shore anglers can land them from piers, jetties, and even right off the beach — particularly along the Jersey Shore and Cape Cod, where the first week of October is widely considered the peak of the fall run. At night, the bite can be every bit as productive as during daylight, with large plugs, bucktail jigs, and live eels all producing big fish. The window is shorter than most anglers expect, so pay attention to water temps and move quickly once reports of the run start coming in.

Northern Pike: Aggressive Hunting in Cold Water

Northern pike are famously aggressive in autumn, becoming even more active and wide-ranging as temperatures drop and they patrol shallower water in search of prey. Unlike summer, when pike tend to stay buried in thick weed cover, fall fish roam more freely and can be encountered along weed edges, deep-water drop-offs, and off the tips of points and islands in five to fifteen feet of water. The feeding frenzy before ice-up means these fish will chase almost anything, making large topwater baits, big spinnerbaits, and diving lures all effective choices depending on conditions. One of the most reliable classic presentations is a large live sucker or panfish suspended beneath a float and worked along the inside edges of drop-offs where baitfish concentrate. On tough days when pike need extra coaxing, slow down and switch to floating-diving lures worked methodically along remaining green weed lines.

Yellow Perch: Easy Limits and the Best-Tasting Fish of Fall

Yellow perch are widely regarded as some of the finest table fare in freshwater, and autumn is when they become genuinely easy to catch in numbers. As the season turns, perch school up in massive hunting packs that move into the shallows, typically staging in five to eight feet of water along the top edges of drop-offs with rocky or sandy bottoms. As water cools further, their diet shifts from small baitfish toward invertebrates and bottom-dwelling forage like crayfish, scuds, and worms — so match your presentation accordingly with small jig heads tipped with chunks of worm or maggots bounced along the bottom. Side-imaging sonar is a serious advantage for locating roaming schools before you set up and fish, but once you find them, the action can be relentless. Lakes Erie and Michigan are legendary fall perch destinations, though productive schools can be found on countless smaller Midwestern and Great Lakes-region fisheries.

More Galleries