Expert Rated Cigars Above $20
Expert Rated Cigars Above $20
<
At a certain price point, a cigar stops being a simple smoke and becomes an experience worth savoring. Premium cigars above $20 represent the upper tier of the craft — where master blenders use aged, carefully sourced tobaccos, apply meticulous construction techniques, and draw on decades of tradition to produce something genuinely exceptional. The difference between a budget smoke and a premium one isn't just marketing; it shows up in the complexity of flavor, the consistency of the draw, and the way the cigar evolves from the first third to the final inch. When evaluating cigars at this level, pay attention to wrapper quality, construction uniformity, burn behavior, and the depth of flavor notes — from earthy and spicy to creamy, sweet, and beyond. Whether you're building a personal collection or simply looking for the best experience your money can buy, understanding what separates good from great is the foundation of a more rewarding relationship with the leaf.
Padron 1964 Torpedo Natural
The Padron 1964 Torpedo Natural is a premium handcrafted cigar from the renowned Padron family, celebrated for its exceptional quality and consistency. Rated 97 out of 100 by experts, it delivers a rich, complex smoking experience with a torpedo shape that concentrates flavors beautifully. Priced at $31.79, it features a natural wrapper that contributes to its smooth, earthy profile. It is ideal for seasoned cigar enthusiasts seeking a top-rated, full-bodied smoke. Buy it now!
Padron Aseries Hermoso Natural
The Padron ASeries Hermoso Natural is a distinguished robusto-style cigar crafted by the prestigious Padron brand, earning an expert rating of 97 out of 100. It offers a well-balanced, full-flavored smoking experience wrapped in a smooth natural leaf. Priced at $24.99, it represents excellent value for a high-caliber cigar from one of the most respected names in the industry. This cigar is a great choice for aficionados who appreciate refined craftsmanship and consistent quality. Buy it now!
Alec Bradley Prensado Churchill
The Alec Bradley Prensado Churchill is a highly acclaimed cigar that earned a 96-point expert rating. It features a rich, complex blend crafted with premium tobaccos that deliver a bold and satisfying smoking experience. The Churchill format offers a generous size ideal for long, leisurely smoke sessions. It is best suited for seasoned cigar enthusiasts who appreciate full-bodied, expertly constructed cigars. Buy it now!
Aging Room Quattro Maestro
The Aging Room Quattro Maestro is a premium belicoso-shaped cigar that has earned an impressive 96-point expert rating. It is crafted with carefully aged tobaccos that produce a nuanced, complex flavor profile with exceptional balance. The belicoso vitola concentrates flavors at the tapered tip, offering a distinctive smoking experience. This cigar is ideal for aficionados seeking a sophisticated, artisan-crafted smoke. Buy it now!
Oliva Serie V Melanio Figurado
The Oliva Serie V Melanio Figurado is a premium figurado-shaped cigar earning an impressive expert rating of 96 out of 100. It features a rich, complex blend known for its bold flavors and exceptional construction. With a 4.6-star customer rating across 12 reviews, it consistently impresses both seasoned aficionados and enthusiastic newcomers. Priced at $26.99, it offers outstanding value for a top-tier smoke. Buy it now!
Padron 80th Anniversary Maduro
The Padron 80th Anniversary Maduro is a distinguished corona-shaped cigar celebrating the Padron family's legacy with an expert rating of 95 out of 100. It showcases a dark, silky maduro wrapper that delivers deep, earthy, and sweet flavor notes with remarkable smoothness. Rated 4.4 stars by customers, it is a beloved choice among premium cigar enthusiasts. Available at $26.99, it represents a milestone release from one of the most respected names in cigars. Buy it now!
Rocky Patel Decade Torpedo
The Rocky Patel Decade Torpedo is a premium handcrafted cigar celebrating a decade of Rocky Patel's blending expertise. It features a rich, aged blend wrapped in a smooth Connecticut Broadleaf maduro wrapper, delivering complex notes of earth, leather, and subtle sweetness. Rated 95 out of 100 by experts, it offers an exceptional smoking experience at an accessible price point. It is ideal for aficionados seeking a full-bodied, well-balanced torpedo-shaped cigar. Buy it now!
Padron 1926 #48 Maduro
The Padron 1926 #48 Maduro is a distinguished toro-sized cigar from Padron's prestigious 1926 Serie, crafted to commemorate the birth year of founder Jose O. Padron. It features a dark, oily maduro wrapper over meticulously aged Nicaraguan long-fillers, producing deep flavors of cocoa, coffee, and rich earth. Earning a 95-point expert rating, it stands among the finest cigars in the Padron portfolio. This cigar is best suited for seasoned smokers who appreciate full-bodied, complex, and luxurious smoking experiences. Buy it now!
Padron Family Reserve No. 50 Natural
The Padron Family Reserve No. 50 Natural is a premium robusto-sized cigar crafted by the renowned Padron family. It features expertly aged tobaccos that deliver a rich, complex smoking experience with exceptional balance and depth. Rated 95 by experts, it stands out for its refined construction and smooth, full-bodied flavor profile. It is ideal for seasoned cigar enthusiasts seeking a luxurious and satisfying smoke. Buy it now!
Fuente Fuente Opus X Double Corona
The Fuente Fuente Opus X Double Corona is a legendary cigar from the Arturo Fuente family, crafted entirely from Dominican-grown tobaccos including a rare Dominican wrapper. It earns a 95 expert rating for its extraordinary complexity, delivering notes of spice, cedar, and rich earthiness. The double corona format provides a long, leisurely smoke that allows the full range of flavors to develop. It is a must-try for collectors and aficionados who appreciate rare, world-class cigars. Buy it now!
Montecristo Platinum Churchill
The Montecristo Platinum Churchill is a premium cigar from the iconic Montecristo brand, presented in the classic Churchill format for a long, satisfying smoke. Rated 94 by experts, it features a carefully selected blend of aged tobaccos that produce a smooth, medium-to-full-bodied experience with notes of cream, cedar, and subtle spice. Its refined construction ensures an even burn and consistent draw throughout. This cigar is well-suited for both seasoned smokers and those looking to explore premium Churchill-sized offerings. Buy it now!
Padron 1964 #4 Maduro
The Padron 1964 #4 Maduro is a premium double toro gordo cigar crafted by the renowned Padron family. It features a rich maduro wrapper that delivers deep, complex flavors with notes of chocolate, coffee, and earth. Aged for a minimum of four years, this cigar offers exceptional smoothness and balance. It is ideal for seasoned cigar enthusiasts seeking a full-bodied, luxurious smoke. Buy it now!
Padron Family Reserve #85 Natural
The Padron Family Reserve #85 Natural is a corona-sized cigar that represents the pinnacle of the Padron family's blending artistry. It features a silky natural wrapper with flavors of cedar, nuts, and subtle sweetness, earning an expert rating of 94. Crafted with aged Nicaraguan tobaccos, it delivers a refined and elegant smoking experience. This cigar is perfect for aficionados who appreciate nuanced, medium-to-full-bodied smokes. Buy it now!
Liga Privada #9 Corona Doble
The Liga Privada #9 Corona Doble is a bold and complex double corona cigar from Drew Estate's acclaimed Liga Privada line. It features a dark, oily Connecticut Broadleaf wrapper paired with a blend of seven rare tobaccos, producing rich flavors of dark chocolate, espresso, and pepper. Rated 94 by experts, it is celebrated for its consistent construction and long, satisfying finish. This cigar is best suited for experienced smokers who enjoy full-bodied, intensely flavored cigars. Buy it now!
Fuente Fuente Opus X Super Belicos
The Fuente Fuente Opus X Super Belicos is a premium belicoso-shaped cigar from the legendary Opus X line by Arturo Fuente. Rated 94 out of 100 by experts, it delivers the rich, complex flavors the Opus X series is renowned for, including notes of spice, cedar, and dark fruit. Crafted with rare Dominican-grown wrapper tobacco, it offers an exceptional smoking experience. It is ideal for aficionados seeking a world-class, highly rated cigar. Buy it now!
Padron 1926 Series No. 9 Natural
The Padron 1926 Series No. 9 Natural is a robusto-sized cigar from Padron's prestigious 1926 Anniversary line, celebrating the birth year of founder José O. Padron. Rated 93 out of 100 by experts, it features a natural sun-grown wrapper and aged tobaccos that deliver a smooth, full-bodied smoke with notes of cocoa, coffee, and earth. Its consistent construction and refined flavor profile make it a standout in the premium cigar category. It is best suited for experienced smokers who appreciate rich, complex, and well-balanced cigars. Buy it now!
Ashton Vsg Torpedo
The Ashton VSG Torpedo is a premium cigar crafted with a rich, full-bodied blend that showcases complex flavors and exceptional construction. Rated 93 by experts, it delivers a sophisticated smoking experience with notes of earth, spice, and cedar. The torpedo shape concentrates the flavors beautifully, making each draw consistently satisfying. It is ideal for experienced cigar enthusiasts seeking a bold and refined smoke. Buy it now!
Padron Diplomatico Maduro
The Padron 1964 Diplomatico Maduro is a double corona-sized cigar from the renowned Padron 1964 Anniversary series, featuring a dark, oily maduro wrapper. Rated 93 by experts, it offers a rich and complex flavor profile with notes of chocolate, coffee, and sweet spice. The maduro wrapper adds a natural sweetness that complements the full-bodied Nicaraguan filler and binder. This cigar is perfect for aficionados who appreciate a long, luxurious smoke with depth and balance. Buy it now!
My Father the Judge Grand Robusto
My Father The Judge Grand Robusto is a highly acclaimed cigar from the My Father Cigars portfolio, earning an expert rating of 93. It features a carefully selected blend of Nicaraguan tobaccos wrapped in a dark, flavorful wrapper that delivers a full-bodied smoking experience. The Grand Robusto vitola provides a generous smoking time with complex notes of leather, dark chocolate, and pepper. This cigar is best suited for seasoned smokers who enjoy bold, well-constructed premium cigars. Buy it now!
Lfd Oro Chisel Tubo
The LFD Oro Chisel Tubo is a figurado-shaped premium cigar presented in an individual tubo for freshness and portability. It earned an expert rating of 93 out of 100, reflecting its exceptional construction and complex flavor profile. The chisel shape offers a unique smoking experience with a tapered head that concentrates the draw. It is an excellent choice for aficionados seeking a high-rated, conveniently packaged cigar. Buy it now!
Ep Carillo Pledge Apogee
The EP Carillo Pledge Apogee is a double toro/gordo vitola crafted by master blender Ernesto Perez-Carrillo. It has earned an expert rating of 93 out of 100 and a perfect 5-star customer rating, highlighting its outstanding quality and consistency. The cigar features a rich, full-bodied blend with complex notes that develop throughout the smoke. It is ideal for seasoned cigar enthusiasts who appreciate expertly crafted, larger-format cigars. Buy it now!
Padron Family Reserve #45 Natural
The Padron Family Reserve #45 Natural is a premium toro-sized cigar from Padron's prestigious Family Reserve line, rated 93 by experts. It features carefully aged Nicaraguan tobaccos wrapped in a natural wrapper, delivering a smooth, complex, and full-bodied profile. The cigar is known for its impeccable construction and rich, nuanced flavors. It is ideal for seasoned cigar aficionados seeking a luxurious and refined smoking experience. Buy it now!
Padron Aseries Hermoso Maduro
The Padron ASeries Hermoso Maduro is a robusto-sized premium cigar featuring a rich maduro wrapper. It carries an expert rating of 93, reflecting its exceptional construction and complex flavor profile. This cigar offers a full-bodied smoking experience with the characteristic depth and smoothness associated with the Padron brand. It is an excellent choice for seasoned cigar enthusiasts who prefer dark, bold wrappers. Buy it now!
Fuente Dc Belicoso
The Fuente DC Belicoso is a premium belicoso-shaped cigar from the renowned Fuente family, earning an expert rating of 93. Its tapered head delivers a concentrated draw that highlights the cigar's nuanced flavors and impeccable craftsmanship. Priced at $23.29, it offers outstanding value for a high-rated premium smoke. This cigar is ideal for aficionados who appreciate the classic belicoso format and Fuente's legendary quality. Buy it now!
Padron 1964 Imperial Natural
The Padron 1964 Imperial Natural is a toro-sized cigar from Padron's celebrated 1964 Anniversary Series, rated 93 by experts. It features a natural wrapper and is crafted from aged Nicaraguan tobaccos, delivering a smooth, medium-to-full-bodied experience with complex notes of cocoa, earth, and spice. Priced at $29.99, it represents a premium offering from one of the most respected names in cigars. It is perfect for discerning smokers who seek a refined and balanced smoke. Buy it now!
Ashton Vsg Spellbound
The Ashton VSG Spellbound is a double corona cigar that earned an impressive expert rating of 93 out of 100. It features the signature VSG (Virgin Sun Grown) wrapper, known for delivering a rich, complex smoking experience with notes of spice, cedar, and earth. This cigar is crafted for aficionados who appreciate bold, full-bodied smokes with exceptional construction. Priced at $21.99, it offers outstanding value for a premium handcrafted cigar. Buy it now!
Fuente Fuente Opus X Robusto Tin
The Fuente Fuente Opus X Robusto Tin is a prestigious cigar presented in a collectible tin, earning an expert rating of 93 out of 100. It features the legendary Opus X Dominican-grown wrapper, delivering a complex profile of rich spice, dark fruit, and cedar. The robusto format offers a satisfying medium-to-full-bodied smoke with impeccable construction. Priced at $63.49, this tin makes an excellent gift or keepsake for serious cigar enthusiasts. Buy it now!
Fuente Fuente Opus X Robusto
The Fuente Fuente Opus X Robusto is a world-renowned cigar that has earned an expert rating of 93 out of 100. Wrapped in a rare Dominican-grown sun-grown wrapper, it delivers a complex and full-bodied experience with flavors of spice, leather, and dark fruit. The robusto vitola provides a perfectly balanced smoke length and ring gauge for a deeply satisfying session. At $21.49, it is a highly sought-after cigar for collectors and connoisseurs alike. Buy it now!
Padron 1926 #6 Natural
The Padron 1926 #6 Natural is a premium corona-sized cigar from Padron's celebrated 1926 Serie, crafted to honor the brand's founder. It features expertly aged Nicaraguan tobaccos that deliver a rich, complex smoking experience with notes of earth, cocoa, and spice. Rated 92 by experts, this cigar has earned a perfect 5-star rating from enthusiast reviewers. It is an excellent choice for seasoned cigar aficionados seeking a refined, full-bodied smoke. Buy it now!
Padron 1964 #4 Natural
The Padron 1964 #4 Natural is a double toro/gordo vitola from Padron's iconic 1964 Anniversary Series, made with sun-grown Nicaraguan tobaccos aged for a minimum of four years. This cigar delivers a smooth, full-bodied profile with complex flavors of coffee, dark chocolate, and cedar. Rated 92 by experts, it represents exceptional craftsmanship and consistency. It is ideal for enthusiasts who appreciate a larger ring gauge with a refined, balanced character. Buy it now!
Padron 1926 #35 Maduro
The Padron 1926 #35 Maduro is a corona-sized cigar from Padron's prestigious 1926 Serie, wrapped in a rich, dark maduro leaf for added sweetness and depth. It features aged Nicaraguan long-fillers that produce a full-bodied smoke with flavors of dark fruit, espresso, and leather. Earning a 92 expert rating, this cigar stands out for its complexity and impeccable construction. It is best suited for maduro lovers who enjoy a bold, nuanced smoking experience. Buy it now!
Padron 1964 Aseries Imperial Maduro
The Padron 1964 ASeries Imperial Maduro is a premium toro-sized cigar crafted with a rich maduro wrapper. It delivers a full-bodied smoking experience with complex flavors characteristic of the renowned Padron 1964 Anniversary Series. The maduro wrapper adds depth with notes of dark chocolate, coffee, and subtle sweetness. It is ideal for seasoned cigar enthusiasts who appreciate bold, well-constructed smokes. Buy it now!
Oliva Serie V Melanio Churchill
The Oliva Serie V Melanio Churchill is a highly rated, full-bodied cigar featuring a Ecuadorian Sumatra wrapper and Nicaraguan filler tobaccos. It earned a 92-point expert rating, reflecting its exceptional construction and complex flavor profile. Smokers can expect rich notes of cedar, dark fruit, espresso, and spice throughout the long, satisfying smoke. This cigar is best suited for experienced aficionados seeking a premium, award-winning Churchill format. Buy it now!
Padron Damaso #12
The Padron Damaso #12 is a robusto-sized cigar crafted by the renowned Padron family. It offers a smooth, medium-bodied smoke with refined flavors characteristic of Padron's quality craftsmanship. Rated 92 points by experts, it delivers excellent value at its price point. It is ideal for enthusiasts seeking a premium everyday smoke. Buy it now!
Padron 1926 No. 1 Natural
The Padron 1926 No. 1 Natural is a Churchill-sized cigar from Padron's prestigious 1926 Series, celebrating the birth year of founder José Orlando Padrón. It features a natural wrapper delivering complex, full-bodied flavors with exceptional balance and depth. Rated 92 points by experts, it represents the pinnacle of Padron's blending artistry. This cigar is best suited for seasoned aficionados who appreciate long, luxurious smoking experiences. Buy it now!
Padron Family Reserve #44 Maduro
The Padron Family Reserve #44 Maduro is a belicoso-shaped cigar wrapped in a rich, dark maduro leaf that imparts deep, complex flavors. Part of Padron's exclusive Family Reserve line, it is crafted with aged tobaccos for a smooth yet full-bodied experience. Rated 92 points by experts and earning a perfect 5-star customer rating, it stands out as a top-tier premium cigar. It is perfect for connoisseurs who favor bold, earthy maduro profiles. Buy it now!
Oliva Serie V Melanio Maduro Churchill
The Oliva Serie V Melanio Maduro Churchill is a full-bodied premium cigar wrapped in a rich maduro leaf. It earned an expert rating of 92 out of 100, reflecting its exceptional construction and complex flavor profile. The Churchill format offers a long, satisfying smoke with deep, earthy notes complemented by the sweetness of the maduro wrapper. It is an excellent choice for experienced cigar enthusiasts seeking a bold and refined smoke. Buy it now!
Oliva Serie V Melanio Torpedo
The Oliva Serie V Melanio Torpedo is a highly regarded premium cigar that has earned a 92 expert rating. Its torpedo shape concentrates the flavors to deliver a rich, complex smoking experience with notes of cocoa, spice, and cedar. Crafted with meticulous attention to detail, this cigar features a beautifully constructed wrapper and an even, consistent burn. It appeals to aficionados who appreciate a well-balanced, full-flavored smoke in a classic torpedo format. Buy it now!
Ashton Vsg Wizard
The Ashton VSG Wizard is a premium toro-sized cigar from the highly acclaimed VSG (Virgin Sun Grown) line, earning a 92 expert rating. It features a sun-grown Ecuadorian wrapper that imparts a distinctive richness and complexity to every draw. The Wizard delivers a full-bodied smoking experience with notes of leather, spice, and dark chocolate. It is ideal for seasoned cigar lovers who seek a bold, expertly crafted smoke. Buy it now!
Diamond Crown Jc Robusto
The Diamond Crown JC Robusto is a distinguished premium cigar crafted in the classic robusto format. Known for its exceptional construction and smooth, refined flavor profile, it offers notes of cream, cedar, and subtle spice. This cigar is part of the prestigious Diamond Crown line, which is celebrated for its consistent quality and luxurious smoking experience. It is a great choice for cigar enthusiasts who appreciate a medium-to-full-bodied smoke with elegant complexity. Buy it now!
Ashton Maduro #60
The Ashton Maduro #60 is a Churchill-sized premium cigar wrapped in a rich, dark maduro leaf. It delivers a smooth, full-bodied smoking experience with notes of chocolate, coffee, and subtle sweetness. Expertly crafted for those who appreciate a bold yet refined smoke, it has earned a 92-point expert rating. It is an excellent choice for seasoned cigar enthusiasts seeking complexity and depth. Buy it now!
Montecristo White Churchill
The Montecristo White Churchill is a premium cigar offering a smooth and refined smoking experience. It features a carefully selected wrapper that delivers a creamy, medium-bodied profile with notes of cedar, cream, and subtle spice. Rated 91 by experts, it has earned strong customer approval with a 4.8 out of 5 star rating. It is an excellent choice for aficionados seeking a classic, well-balanced Churchill format. Buy it now!
Aging Room Quattro Vibrato
The Aging Room Quattro Vibrato is a Toro-sized cigar crafted with meticulous attention to blending and aging. It carries an expert rating of 91 and a perfect 5-star customer rating, reflecting its exceptional quality and consistency. The cigar delivers a complex, medium-to-full-bodied experience with layered flavors that appeal to seasoned smokers. It is ideal for enthusiasts who appreciate artisanal construction and nuanced flavor profiles. Buy it now!
Padron 1926 #6 Maduro
The Padron 1926 #6 Maduro is a corona-sized cigar from Padron's prestigious 1926 Series, crafted to celebrate the brand's founder's birth year. It features a rich maduro wrapper that delivers deep, complex flavors with notes of chocolate, coffee, and earth. Rated 91 by experts, this cigar is known for its exceptional construction and consistent burn. It is an ideal choice for seasoned cigar enthusiasts seeking a full-bodied, premium smoke. Buy it now!
Montecristo White Court Tube
The Montecristo White Court Tube is a refined corona-sized cigar from the acclaimed Montecristo White Series, conveniently packaged in an elegant tube for freshness and portability. It has earned a 91 expert rating and a Top Pick designation, reflecting its outstanding quality and flavor profile. The cigar offers a smooth, medium-bodied experience with creamy notes and subtle spice. It is perfect for aficionados who appreciate a polished, well-balanced smoke in a travel-friendly format. Buy it now!
Padron 1964 Aseries Exclusivo Maduro
The Padron 1964 ASeries Exclusivo Maduro is a premium double corona cigar from Padron's celebrated 1964 Anniversary Series. It features a rich maduro wrapper that delivers deep, complex flavors with the hallmark smoothness and balance the 1964 line is known for. Rated 91 by experts, it has earned a perfect 5-star customer rating. It is an excellent choice for seasoned cigar enthusiasts seeking a full-bodied, refined smoke. Buy it now!
Padron 1926 #35 Natural
The Padron 1926 #35 Natural is a corona-sized cigar from Padron's prestigious 1926 Series, crafted to commemorate the founder's birth year. It features a natural wrapper and delivers the complex, full-bodied flavor profile that defines the 1926 line, including notes of earth, cocoa, and spice. Rated 91 by experts, it carries a 4.8-star customer rating. It is ideal for aficionados who appreciate a well-constructed, medium-to-full-bodied smoke. Buy it now!
Padron 1964 Aseries Exclusivo Natural
The Padron 1964 ASeries Exclusivo Natural is a premium double corona cigar from the renowned Padron 1964 Anniversary Series. It features a natural wrapper and is crafted with aged Nicaraguan tobaccos, delivering a rich and complex smoking experience. With an expert rating of 91 and a 4.8-star customer rating, it is highly regarded for its consistency and quality. It is an excellent choice for seasoned cigar enthusiasts seeking a full-bodied, refined smoke. Buy it now!
La Aroma De Cuba Mi Amor Freshpack
The La Aroma de Cuba Mi Amor Freshpack is a premium cigar gift pack offering a convenient and fresh way to enjoy this celebrated blend. Rated 91 out of 100 by experts, it delivers a rich and complex smoking experience with exceptional construction. The freshpack format ensures optimal humidity and freshness right out of the package. It is an ideal choice for cigar enthusiasts looking for a high-quality, ready-to-smoke gift option. Buy it now!
Padron Family Reserve #45 Maduro
The Padron Family Reserve #45 Maduro is a belicoso-shaped premium cigar crafted with aged Nicaraguan tobaccos and a rich maduro wrapper. Earning an expert rating of 91 out of 100, it offers a full-bodied profile with notes of dark chocolate, espresso, and earthy sweetness. The Family Reserve line represents some of Padron's finest work, featuring meticulously selected and aged leaves for a refined smoking experience. It is best suited for seasoned cigar aficionados who appreciate bold, complex flavors. Buy it now!
More Galleries
