14 High-Performing Cigars To Enjoy Right Now
14 High-Performing Cigars To Enjoy Right Now
<
Premium cigar making has never been more exciting — or more competitive. From fifth-generation family dynasties working century-old Dominican estates to boutique blenders pushing Nicaraguan Corojo to its limits, the range of world-class cigars available today is staggering. The cigars on this list were chosen for consistent high scores across major publications, memorable tasting profiles, and genuine staying power in the humidor. Whether you lean toward a rich, full-bodied Nicaraguan puro or a structured, medium-bodied Dominican classic, there is something here worth smoking. Each entry represents a high-performing stick that has earned its place through tobacco, craftsmanship, and reputation — not just hype.
My Father The Judge: Cigar Aficionado's 2024 Cigar of the Year
The Judge Grand Robusto earned the top spot on Cigar Aficionado's 2024 list, a milestone that reflects the extraordinary trajectory of the Garcia family's Nicaraguan operation. The cigar features a rich, oily wrapper encasing an all-Nicaraguan blend, delivering notes of earthy spice, dark chocolate, and a hint of pepper on the first draw, with leather and wood evolving through the smoke. Its complexity is matched by a smooth, even-burning construction that holds its line right to the nub. The Garcia family — led by Don Pepin Garcia and his son Jaime — has become synonymous with full-bodied Nicaraguan excellence, and The Judge is arguably their defining statement. For aficionados who appreciate a powerful yet refined smoke, this grand robusto sets a benchmark for what Nicaraguan tobacco can achieve. Buy it now!
Padrón 1964 Anniversary Maduro: The Nicaraguan Gold Standard
Few cigars in the world have appeared on as many year-end lists as the Padrón 1964 Anniversary Series Maduro, which earned its fourth Cigar Snob Top 25 appearance in 2024 — including a previous Cigar of the Year win in 2019. The line celebrates the year José Orlando Padrón founded the company in Miami's Little Havana and is built from Nicaraguan tobaccos aged for a minimum of four years, producing a dense, layered profile of cocoa, coffee, and earth with a distinctly creamy finish. Its characteristic box-press delivers a firm, consistent draw and an impeccably even burn from start to finish. The maduro torpedo format in particular stands out for its tapered draw that concentrates flavour intensity in every puff. For seasoned smokers looking for absolute consistency alongside profound complexity, Padrón 1964 remains the benchmark by which Nicaraguan cigars are judged. Buy it now!
Liga Privada No. 9: Drew Estate's Private Blend Gone Public
The Liga Privada No. 9 began as a personal project — Steve Saka, then president of Drew Estate, wanted the factory to make a cigar he would actually want to smoke, and after testing over 50 blends, the ninth formula emerged as the definitive answer. Made at La Gran Fabrica in Estelí, Nicaragua, it pairs an oily Connecticut Broadleaf #1 Darks wrapper with a Brazilian Mata Fina binder and long-fillers from seven different Honduran and Nicaraguan farms, all aged for an extra year before rolling. The result is a full-bodied but remarkably smooth smoke opening with creamy milk chocolate and coffee before transitioning through baking spice, nutmeg, and cocoa powder, with leather and dark fruit arriving in the final third. Cigar Aficionado rated the Toro a 94, noting a complex range of earthy flavours and a sweet, tarry finish. It became a cult cigar almost immediately upon its 2011 commercial release, and it has never stopped earning that reputation. Buy it now!
Fuente Fuente OpusX: The Dominican Puro That Changed Everything
When Carlito Fuente and his father Carlos successfully cultivated a wrapper-quality leaf on their Dominican estate in the early 1990s — a feat previously considered impossible — the result was the Fuente Fuente OpusX, released in 1996 and still regarded as one of the most iconic luxury cigars ever produced. The estate, Chateau de la Fuente, sits on mineral-rich volcanic soil in the Cibao Valley, and the tobacco grown there gives the OpusX its distinctive character: a full-bodied powerhouse of leather, earth, dark coffee, and cocoa, with an intriguing note of sweetness on the finish. Each leaf is selected from a private reserve set aside exclusively for the blend, and only the best rollers in the factory are permitted to work on it. The Box Pressed Toro has earned as high as a 95 from Cigar Aficionado, and the cigar's limited availability continues to make every encounter with it feel like an occasion. For fans of Dominican tobacco at its absolute apex, OpusX remains the single most important cigar the Fuente family has ever made. Buy it now!
Oliva Serie V Melanio: Nicaragua's Most Decorated Toro
Named after Melanio Oliva, the patriarch who first planted tobacco in Nicaragua for the family in the 1880s, the Serie V Melanio is built around a rare Sumatra-seed wrapper grown in Ecuador and a premium blend of Nicaraguan tobaccos selected to complement it. The resulting profile is rich and full-bodied, cycling through dark chocolate, espresso, and black pepper before settling into a subtle sweetness and creamy smoothness in the final third. Construction is consistently praised for its perfect draw and an even, slow-burning ash that holds firm well into the second third. The Melanio has become one of Oliva's flagship expressions, regularly cited as one of the finest Nicaraguan cigars in regular production at any price. Its combination of complexity, construction quality, and availability at a mid-range price point makes it a consistent recommendation from expert reviewers. Buy it now!
Ashton VSG Torpedo: 25 Years of Ecuadorian Sun-Grown Dominance
Since its debut in 1999, the Ashton VSG has navigated every trend in the premium cigar world — from the Connecticut shade era to the maduro revolution and back — while remaining consistently beloved by aficionados who value refinement over extremity. Made by Tabacalera A. Fuente in the Dominican Republic, the VSG uses an Ecuador Sun Grown wrapper over a seven-filler combination of tobaccos inside, producing a savory, complex, and full-bodied experience anchored in natural sweetness, earth, leather, and spice. The torpedo format, which earned a 91-point rating from Cigar Snob in its 2024 Top 25, allows the blend's tapered construction to concentrate its flavour in a way the standard sizes cannot quite match. Its longevity on best-of lists is a testament to quality, longevity, and a brand that has always known what it is. Pair it with a single-malt Scotch for a combination that plays directly into the cigar's woody, spiced character. Buy it now!
E.P. Carrillo Encore Celestial: Blending Virtuosity in a Box Press
Ernesto Pérez-Carrillo is one of the most respected names in modern cigar making, having built his reputation first at La Gloria Cubana before launching his own brand out of a 40,000-square-foot facility in Santiago's Zona Franca. The Encore Celestial — released in 2018 as a follow-up to the acclaimed La Historia — scored 92 points at both its initial Cigar Snob review and the magazine's year-end 2024 tastings, a remarkable display of consistency across six years of production. The impeccably pressed 6⅛ × 50 format features a Nicaraguan wrapper and binder over Nicaraguan fillers, producing a medium-to-full-bodied smoke of considerable depth and balance. Tasting notes run through cedar, dark fruit, and spice with a smooth, lingering finish that rewards slow smoking. For those who value the craft of blending as an art form, the Encore Celestial is among the clearest expressions of Pérez-Carrillo's genius. Buy it now!
Davidoff Winston Churchill The Late Hour: Single Malt Meets Havana Leaf
Davidoff's Winston Churchill series is already one of the most distinguished lines in Dominican cigar making, but The Late Hour takes the concept further by incorporating leaves aged in single malt whisky casks into the blend — a nod to Churchill's legendary habit of pairing cigars with a late-evening dram. The resulting flavour profile is genuinely unusual: dark chocolate and coffee sit alongside a distinctive whisky-tinged warmth and a subtle smokiness that sets it apart from any standard Dominican blend. Made at Altadis's La Romana facility in the Dominican Republic, the construction is flawless — as you would expect from a brand synonymous with Swiss precision and luxury. The Late Hour is medium-to-full in body, making it accessible enough for regular smoking without losing any of its evening-appropriate sophistication. For the gentleman who pairs his cigars with Scotch, it is a rare case of a cigar that has done the pairing work for you.
Cohiba Riviera Robusto: San Andrés Maduro Meets American Cohiba
The Cohiba Riviera Robusto — a strong Cigar Aficionado performer — showcases the American Cohiba line at its most adventurous, pairing a stunning Mexican San Andrés wrapper with a Honduran binder and a carefully curated blend of Nicaraguan and Honduran fillers. The 5½ × 50 format produces a rich and dynamic profile: cocoa, roasted coffee, and a touch of black pepper on the palate, balanced by a subtle sweetness and creamy undertones that persist right through the finish. Construction earns consistent praise for its flawless presentation, smooth draw, and a slow, even burn that confirms the quality of the leaf selection. The Riviera sits comfortably in the medium-to-full category, making it an excellent choice for aficionados who want the Cohiba prestige without committing to a prolonged two-hour smoke. Paired with a dark rum or an aged bourbon, it is among the most food-friendly cigars currently in the Cohiba portfolio. Buy it now!
Plasencia Cosecha 151 La Música: A Family Tobacco Dynasty's Finest
The Plasencia name has been central to Central American tobacco farming for decades — Nestor Plasencia and his sons have supplied leaf to some of the world's most respected blenders while quietly building their own brand into one of the most acclaimed in the industry. The Cosecha 151 La Música, a standout on Cigar Aficionado's 2024 list, carries a medium-to-full strength that balances power and elegance with impressive discipline. Dark chocolate, roasted coffee, and creamy undertones build through the first third before a dry spice note adds complexity in the second and final portions. Flawless construction allows the intricate flavours to unfold with every puff rather than overwhelming the palate at once. For aficionados drawn to cigars with a genuine backstory in the soil, Plasencia's ability to control the entire seed-to-box process gives La Música a terroir-driven authenticity that few blended cigars can claim.
HVC Selección No. 1: Cuban Heritage Reborn in Nicaraguan Leaf
HVC Cigars was founded in 2011 by master blender Reiner Lorenzo, who spent his formative years learning the craft in Cuba before relocating to Nicaragua in 2008 and later establishing the brand to honour his roots in Havana City. The Selección No. 1 is crafted with premium Nicaraguan tobacco and wrapped in Ecuadorian Habano seed leaf, positioning it firmly in the medium-to-full-bodied category with an after-dinner profile that rewards patience and a slow pace. Subtle hints of cedar, cinnamon, and coffee develop from the first third and maintain a satisfying consistency through to the final puffs, with no harshness or spikes in strength. HVC hand-rolls its cigars in the true Cuban tradition using intricate manual filling and pressing techniques, resulting in a quality of construction that punches well above its relatively modest price point. For aficionados who value the Old Havana aesthetic but want it expressed through premium Nicaraguan leaf, the Selección No. 1 is one of the most honest expressions of that lineage currently available. Buy it now!
Tatuaje Reserva A Uno: Pete Johnson's Rarest Limited Edition
Pete Johnson of Tatuaje Cigars has built one of the most loyal followings in boutique cigar making through a combination of inspired blending, limited releases, and a genuine refusal to compromise on tobacco quality. The Reserva A Uno — crafted at the My Father Cigars factory in Nicaragua and appearing on Cigar Aficionado's Top 25 of 2024 — features a rich Ecuadorian Habano wrapper over a Nicaraguan binder and filler, delivering a full-bodied experience built on dark chocolate, roasted coffee, and creamy undertones that deepen as the smoke progresses. As a limited-edition release, it represents Johnson at his most ambitious: a cigar blended not for the mass market but for the smoker who will appreciate every transition from first light to the final inch. Tatuaje's reputation for using well-aged tobacco ensures that each stick smokes with the kind of seamless consistency that only time in the aging room can provide. This is a cigar to acquire in multiples if you encounter it — it will not linger on shelves. Buy it now!
Herrera Estelí Norteño: Drew Estate's Underrated Workhorse Toro
Released in 2014 as a follow-up to the original Herrera Estelí line, the Norteño was blended by Drew Estate's master blender Willy Herrera and has made three appearances on Cigar Snob's Top 25 list — including a 91-point showing in 2024 — despite being consistently overlooked relative to the more high-profile Liga Privada family. The 6 × 50 Toro Especial combines a Mexican San Andrés wrapper with a Honduran binder and Nicaraguan fillers, producing a rich, full-bodied profile with notes of cocoa, cedar, subtle spice, and earth that builds steadily from start to finish. At around $11 per stick, it represents exceptional value for a cigar of this construction quality and flavour depth. The blend is made at Drew Estate's La Gran Fabrica in Estelí — the same factory responsible for Liga Privada — and shares that line's obsessive attention to rolling quality. Smokers who love the Liga Privada character but want it at a more accessible everyday price point should have a box of Norteño Toro Especial in their rotation at all times.
Joya de Nicaragua Cinco de Cinco: A Milestone Maduro Masterpiece
Rated 93 points and crowned Cigar Snob Magazine's Cigar of the Year for 2024, the Cinco de Cinco Toro represents a genuine pinnacle for Nicaragua's oldest premium cigar factory. The name references both the company's 55th anniversary and the cigar's self-proclaimed five-out-of-five quality standard — a bold claim the blend more than backs up. Built on a Mexican San Andrés maduro wrapper over Nicaraguan binder and filler, it manages the rare trick of being deeply flavorful while carrying the nuanced, transitional profile of a much lighter cigar. The complexity is off the charts, cycling through multiple flavour chapters from first light to the final third. It is one of the few maduros on the market that can satisfy both the hardcore strength-seeker and the complexity-focused aficionado simultaneously.
More Galleries
