16 BBQ Myths That Won't Die

The Backyard Is Full of Old Wives' Tales

<

Few hobbies produce as many confident opinions as barbecue. Rules passed from fathers, pitmasters, TV chefs and cooking forums shape how people grill and smoke, and many of them sound so sensible that nobody checks. Food scientists and test cooks have spent years doing exactly that, with thermometers, scales and side-by-side cooks, and the results often overturn tradition. The sixteen myths below come from barbecue science writers, test kitchens and grilling-company explainers, including measured experiments with temperatures, weights and times. Where the findings are close or disputed, the entries say so, and the numbers come from individual tests, which can vary with equipment and cuts. Some of the myths involve safety, so the entries note the temperatures recommended for different meats. Others concern flavor, texture or technique. The point is not that tradition is worthless. Plenty of old habits work, though not always for the reasons given. A better understanding of what is really happening can make you more relaxed and more consistent behind the grill. It also saves time, since several popular rituals are optional. A good thermometer and an open mind go a long way.

Myth: Searing Seals In the Juices

The idea that a hot sear locks moisture inside a steak is one of the most persistent in cooking, and it is false. Test cooks and food scientists have measured it repeatedly. A well-known comparison found that seared-first meats lost about 1.68 percent more liquid than meat cooked without searing, and another test reported that a seared steak lost about 6 percent more juices than an identical unseared steak. The claim dates back to the nineteenth century, and a barbecue science site notes that the concept was debunked in the early 1900s but lives on. Searing's real benefit is flavor. The browning of the surface, through the Maillard reaction and caramelization, creates hundreds of flavor compounds and a crisp crust. Cooks who sear first or last get the same crust, and a reverse sear, in which the steak is cooked slowly and seared at the end, often gives a more even interior. The key to juicy meat is not overcooking it, so use a thermometer and pull the steak when it reaches the target temperature. Sear for flavor and texture, and stop worrying about sealing.

Myth: Pink Meat Is Undercooked

Color is a poor guide to doneness, and cooks who rely on it can undercook or overcook. What matters is the internal temperature. Ground beef can turn brown before it reaches a safe 160 degrees Fahrenheit, while poultry can look pink even when done, because marrow can seep into the bones of young birds. Recommended safe temperatures are about 160 degrees for ground meats, 145 degrees for beef, lamb and veal steaks and roasts, and 145 degrees for fish, with poultry at 165 according to the standard guidance for whole birds. Smoked meats can stay pink at safe temperatures because of the smoke ring and the gases in the cooking environment. A reliable instant-read thermometer takes the guesswork out of the process. Insert it into the thickest part, away from bone, and check more than one spot. Do not poke repeatedly. The color of the meat after cooking depends on the pigment myoglobin, the cooking method, the age of the animal and the pH, and not just on the heat it has received. Trust the thermometer, not your eyes.

Myth: The Red Liquid in Meat Is Blood

When a package of beef or a resting steak leaks a red liquid, most people assume it is blood. It is not. By the time meat reaches the store, the animal has been bled during processing, and very little blood remains in the muscle. The red liquid is mostly water mixed with myoglobin, a protein that carries oxygen in muscle cells and turns pink when mixed with water. Meat is about 82 percent water, so there is plenty to release. The color explains why a steak looks red or pink and why some cooked meats leave pink juices on the plate. Understanding this removes a common squeamishness and a common mistake, which is to cook meat until the liquid runs clear as a sign of doneness. Juice color tells you very little about whether meat is safe. The real test is temperature. The same myoglobin is responsible for the deep red color of rare beef and the pink of the smoke ring. It is a useful reminder that much of what we think we see in meat has a simple explanation in chemistry.

Myth: The Smoke Ring Proves Great Barbecue

The pink band just under the surface of smoked meat is admired in competitions, and it has become a symbol of quality. In fact, it is mostly aesthetic. The ring is a chemical reaction in which gases from combustion, such as nitrogen oxides and carbon monoxide, interact with myoglobin and fix its pink color. It can form even when there is no smoke, for example, from a gas oven, and it does not affect taste. A barbecue science site says it results from a reaction with the gases, not the smoke flavor, and another source notes that sources disagree somewhat on the mechanism but agree that the ring says little about flavor or skill. Some pitmasters coax a ring with tricks like salt, and some competitions have debated whether to score it. The best barbecue is judged by flavor, tenderness and moisture. A beautiful ring is a pleasant bonus, but not proof of a great cook. If your brisket lacks one, it does not mean you did anything wrong. Focus on temperature control, seasoning and patience instead.

Myth: More Smoke Means More Flavor

Beginners often try to fill the smoker with as much smoke as possible, and the food suffers. Thick white or black smoke is a sign of incomplete combustion, and it deposits bitter, sooty compounds on the meat. What you want is thin, almost invisible blue smoke, which comes from a clean-burning fire with good airflow. A barbecue science source puts it plainly: thick white smoke can make the barbecue taste bitter, and thin blue smoke is the target. Keep the fire hot enough to burn the wood cleanly, give it enough oxygen with open vents and use dry, seasoned wood. Add small amounts of wood at a time, not a heap. Meat absorbs most of its smoke flavor early in the cook, so you do not need to smoke it for the entire time. Too much smoke can overpower the food, particularly lean meats like chicken and fish. Learning to read the smoke is a skill that improves with practice. A quiet, steady plume is the sign of a good fire, and the result is a clean, balanced flavor that enhances the meat.

Myth: Soaking Wood Chips Gives Better Smoke

Many recipes tell cooks to soak wood chips or chunks in water, or in beer, wine or juice, to make them smoke longer or add flavor. Tests show that water barely penetrates wood. Chips soaked for twelve hours absorbed about 6 percent water, and chunks about 3 percent, so the effect is negligible, according to a barbecue science writer. Another source says studies show the water mostly steams off before the wood actually smokes. Wet wood cannot rise above the boiling point of water until it dries, which delays the smoldering that produces smoke and can create dirty, smoldering fires that taste bitter. Soaking in flavorful liquids is also unlikely to transfer flavor, because the liquid does not penetrate deeply and the aromas burn off. Dry wood burns cleanly and produces cleaner smoke. If you want to extend smoke time, use larger chunks, add wood in stages or use a smoke box. For a charcoal grill, place dry wood on the coals. The only case where soaking has any use is a half-and-half mix of wet and dry wood for a delayed start. Otherwise, skip the soak.

Myth: Beer Can Chicken Steams in Beer Flavor

Perched on a half-empty can of beer, a chicken is supposed to be moistened and flavored by the steam. A series of measurements says otherwise. The can stays cool: in one test it was 130 degrees Fahrenheit when the outside of the chicken hit 185. The beer never reaches boiling at 212 degrees, so little steam is produced, and the can blocks airflow inside the bird, which risks undercooking the cavity. Chicken is done at 165 degrees, as measured in the thickest part of the thigh and breast. The technique does give the bird an upright stance that lets the skin cook evenly and the fat drain away, which are real benefits. For flavor, marinate the chicken, inject it with a seasoned liquid or season the cavity directly. A vertical roaster stand, which does the same job without a can, is a better choice. There is also a concern about heating painted aluminum cans. The recipe survives because it is memorable and produces good results, but the beer is not the reason. Let it go, and use a thermometer instead.

Myth: The Stall Happens When Connective Tissue Breaks Down

Anyone who smokes brisket or pork butt meets the stall, when the internal temperature stops rising for hours, often in the range of 150 to 170 degrees Fahrenheit. A popular explanation says it is caused by connective tissue breaking down, but a barbecue science source says the real cause is evaporation: as moisture leaves the surface of the meat, it cools the meat, just as sweat cools skin. When evaporative cooling equals the heat input, the temperature plateaus. Wrapping the meat in foil or butcher paper blocks evaporation and shortens the stall. In one test, a wrapped pork butt reached 198 degrees five hours sooner, and another expert estimates that wrapping speeds the cook by about four hours. The trade-off is a softer bark. Some pitmasters wrap late or use butcher paper as a compromise. Others simply wait out the stall. Knowing the cause lets you decide what to do. If time matters, wrap. If you want a firm, crusty bark, ride it out. Either way, remember to cook to tenderness, not just to a number.

Myth: Steaks Must Come to Room Temperature First

Cooking advice often says to take meat out of the refrigerator an hour or two before grilling so it cooks evenly. Experiments show the effect is small. The recommended warm-up of about twenty minutes does little, and a steak was still not near room temperature after two hours, according to a barbecue science writer. Meanwhile, leaving raw meat on the counter allows bacteria to grow, particularly if it is out for long. Keeping meat at 40 degrees or below and cooking it soon after removing it from the refrigerator is safer. A cold steak actually has an advantage: a cold interior stays rarer while the surface sears. For thicker cuts, a reverse sear or a slow, gentle approach gives evenness regardless of starting temperature. Salting the steak in advance, a dry brine, does more for flavor and juiciness than letting it sit out. Pat the surface dry before it hits the heat, since moisture hinders browning. The tip persists because it sounds sensible and feels like a courtesy to the meat. Rather than waiting, spend the time preheating the grill and preparing sides.

Myth: Flip the Steak Only Once

The one-flip rule is repeated by grill masters and parents everywhere, as though turning a steak more than once were a sin. Tests suggest the opposite can be useful. Turning the steak often can cook meat up to 30 percent faster, according to one test, and it produces more even cooking, because each side has a chance to cool slightly before the heat builds again. Frequent flipping can also yield flatter ribeyes, with less of a doming effect. The crust develops as the surface dries and browns, and frequent turns do not prevent it. Pitmasters who cook by feel often flip several times. The best method depends on the cut and the equipment. For a thin steak over high heat, a single flip is fine. For a thick steak, turning every minute or so can help the center cook before the outside burns. The most important tool is a thermometer, not a rule. Pull the steak when it reaches 5 to 10 degrees below your target, and let it rest. Flip as often as you like, and be wary of rules that claim there is only one way.

Myth: Lifting the Lid Ruins the Cook

The saying if you're lookin', you ain't cookin' is meant to stop cooks from opening the grill or smoker too often. In tests, lifting the lid caused no significant heat loss for the meat. The food kept cooking, even though the air temperature in the cooker took up to fifteen minutes to recover in some trials. The mass of the meat, the grates and the walls of the cooker hold heat far better than the air. On a charcoal or wood fire, opening the lid also lets in oxygen, which can stoke the fire briefly. There are limits. Leaving the lid off for a long time will slow the cook and can cool a thin cut, and flare-ups can happen when oxygen rushes in. The practical rule is to open the lid when you need to, such as to check temperature, move meat, baste or add wood, and then close it. It is better to look than to guess. Opening the lid to spritz a brisket or rotate ribs is normal for experienced cooks. The myth survives because it sounds like a rule of patience, but patience is about timing, not never looking.

Myth: Grill Marks Mean a Great Steak

Dark stripes on a steak look impressive, and many people treat them as a sign of quality. In fact, grill marks are superficial. They are caused by the metal grates conducting heat to the meat in thin lines, which brown only those areas. The rest of the surface stays pale. A better crust comes from searing the entire surface, which creates more of the Maillard browning that gives steak its savory flavor. To get an even crust, use a flat-top, a cast iron skillet or a griddle plate, or move the meat so it contacts hot metal evenly. Some cooks rotate steaks a quarter turn to create crosshatch marks, which look nice but add little flavor. For quick-cooking items such as shrimp, thin fish and vegetables, grill marks are a pleasant bonus and help the food cook in the short time available. For thick steaks, they are secondary. The presentation can still matter, and there is no harm in marks. But if flavor is the goal, aim for a full crust. Eat with your mouth, not your eyes, and judge the steak by how it tastes.

Myth: Boil the Ribs First to Make Them Tender

Boiling ribs before grilling is a shortcut some cooks swear by, and it is a mistake. Boiling pulls flavor, vitamins and minerals out of the meat and into the water, and it leaves the texture mushy and watery. Real tenderness in ribs comes from time and gentle heat, which slowly melt collagen into gelatin. Cooking low and slow, in a smoker or oven at around 225 to 275 degrees Fahrenheit, takes a few hours and gives the meat a bite that pulls cleanly from the bone. If you need to speed things up, steam or roast the ribs in foil first, or use the foil wrap technique partway through the cook. A barbecue science source recommends cooking ribs to an internal temperature of about 190 to 203 degrees, then checking with a toothpick for tenderness. The pull-back of the meat from the bones is not a reliable indicator. The finishing glaze or sauce goes on near the end to prevent burning. Boiled ribs may be tender, but they lack the flavor and texture that make barbecue special. Patience is the secret ingredient.

Myth: More BTUs Means a Hotter Grill

Grill specifications love to quote BTUs, which stands for British thermal units. They measure the heat the burners can produce per hour, not the temperature of the cooking surface. A grill with huge BTU numbers can be inefficient if the lid leaks, the firebox is large or the heat escapes through the sides. The actual cooking temperature depends on the size of the grill, the insulation, how well it holds heat, the distance between burners and grates and how it is controlled. A well-designed grill with fewer BTUs may reach higher temperatures than a leaky model with many. A better way to compare is BTUs per square inch of cooking area, which gives a sense of heat density, and to look at construction: thick castings, tight lids and sturdy materials. A built-in thermometer helps, but an independent one at grate level is more accurate. Preheat for ten to fifteen minutes before cooking. The number on the box is a marketing figure. Focus on build quality, even heat across the grates and the ability to hold a steady temperature, and use a thermometer to verify.

Myth: Spray Water on Flare-Ups

A spray bottle is a staple at many grills, and it is used to knock down flare-ups when fat drips onto the coals. Water on grease can make matters worse, spitting hot oil and creating steam that burns, and on a charcoal fire, it sends ash onto the food. A better approach is to starve the flame of oxygen. Close the lid and the vents for a moment, or move the food to a cooler zone of the grill until the flames die down. Setting up a two-zone fire, with coals on one side and none on the other, gives a safe place to retreat. Trim excess fat from meat, avoid heavy oil marinades dripping onto the fire and keep the grill clean, since built-up grease is fuel. Keep a fire extinguisher rated for grease fires nearby, and never leave a grill unattended. Do not use water on a grease fire, which can spread it. For gas grills, turn off the burners and close the lid. Preparation prevents most flare-ups. When one does happen, calm, quick action is better than splashing.

Myth: Marinades Soak Deep Into the Meat

Marinades are loved for the idea that the flavor soaks into the meat overnight. In reality, they penetrate only about a quarter of an inch, according to a barbecue science writer. The inner parts of a thick cut remain unflavored, which is why a marinated steak can taste seasoned on the surface and plain at the center. Acids in marinades, such as citrus or vinegar, can make the surface mushy if left too long. Alcohol should be burned off before serving. Forking the meat does not help, as the holes close quickly and fill with juice rather than marinade, and it can drive surface bacteria deeper. Better options include salting or dry brining in advance, which helps the meat hold moisture, and injecting a liquid with a syringe for deeper penetration. Brines work by osmosis and diffusion, carrying salt and flavor deeper. A marinade is still useful for surface flavor, tenderizing thin cuts and creating a crust, but it is not a deep-flavor delivery system. Set expectations accordingly. For big roasts and briskets, inject or brine for flavor that goes all the way through.

More Galleries